Bicycles on Trains: Updated ... Again!

Original Post, 3/30/08: Bicycle parking on trains (and at train stations) is needed to promote multi-modal transportation and reduce automobile use, particularly in compact areas like Downtown New Haven. Numerous other cities and regions allow bicycles on trains - why not Metro North? Recently, controversy has erupted over the state's promises to include some bicycle parking on its newly-ordered train cars, as well as whether or not cyclists will be barred from peak-hour trains. See more information here and here.

After a disappointing discussion with the Connecticut Commuter Council, cyclists from New Haven and other parts of Connecticut and the region attended the MTA President's Forum in New York City in late March 2008; the New Haven Independent reports here.

Selected comments from the MTA President's Forum article:

Patrick, on MNR President Cannito: "Does he simply dismiss all of us who would be using the Metro-Northbetween Connecticut stations? It's incredibly frustrating for me because I travel between New Haven and Bridgeport and would like to use my bike as transportation to and from both stations. I'm not in the proper cycling shape to do a 50 mile commute every day, but I canand love to handle the 16 miles+train ride. Cannito also doesn't seem to be thinking about the future."

David Streever: "Despite assurances from them, they have now reneged, with neither an explanation nor a rationale for why they previously indicated they would provide dedicated bike parking."

Charlie: "The thousands of commuters currently traveling from New Haven to Stamford (or vice versa) each day can take the train, but often have to take 4 car trips per day to and from the stations. That's a recipe for gridlock, environmental degradation, urban decay, and overall social collapse."

Gary Doyens: "Some of you want to levy extra taxes, spend tax dollars for bike lanes and even more tax dollars so you can ride the train with your bike. Why is that our responsibility?"

Robn: "cyclists have been subsidizing both car and rail for years and its time for a bit of payback."

DowntownNewHaven (Moderator 06510): "You can't look at MNRR and just analyze the trains themselves in some sort of bizarre vacuum. You have to look at the tens of thousands of parking spaces taking up valuable land around the train station (land that could probably be rented for $50-$100/SF, and produce incredible tax revenue for the communities nearby, but instead is used to subsidize parking for drivers), the traffic created by said stations, etc., among many other factors."

Many downtown residents are writing letters to Governor Rell, elected officials, DOT administrators and others. Local bicyclists are encouraging everyone to write or call in on the issue (also see here). Discussion is continuing on the ElmCityCycling listserv.

Update 4/10/08: The New Haven Advocate reports today that bicycle "tie-downs" will be included on some trains, but that bicycles will still be prohibited from trains at peak hours.

Update 4/28/08: A thoughtful op-ed on the subject of bicycles on trains appeared in the Hartford Courant, with several comments. Further discussion and complaints have also erupted over postings by Jim Cameron, Chairman of the Connecticut Commuter Council, on his personal blog site. Discussion also continues on the ElmCityCycling listserv.

From the Courant op-ed: "Many employment centers along the New Haven line are too far from stations to be reached on foot, but can be easily accessed by bicycle. Having appropriate bicycle storage areas for train users would expand Metro-North's potential pool of riders, while doing nothing to exclude its existing ridership. One can look to many train lines across the U.S. and Europe for models of successful bicycle-train integration, including Caltrain, Metrolink, Tri-Rail, the California-Amtrak Surfliner and Capitol Corridor trains, and the Berlin S-Bahn, to name only a few."

Update 5/8/08: Richard Stowe refutes all of the points in Jim Cameron's article.

Update 5/28/08: An excellent feature article on the topic of bicycles on trains appeared on the front page of today's Hartford Courant. The article also features coverage of the recent National Train Day event in Downtown New Haven:

Rep. Mary Mushinsky, D-Wallingford, spoke about a second attempt to pass legislation letting bikes on peak Metro-North trains, particularly the new M-8 cars purchased almost entirely with state money. Your best friend is the price of oil," she told them. "We're looking at $150 a barrel this summer and $200 next year. It will be unaffordable for some people to commute to work next year."

Jason Stockmann, a graduate student at Yale, quietly took notes. He works on medical imaging at Yale and recently put his car into storage. Bike tie-downs are critical for the new trains, he said later."If we miss this opportunity it could be a really long time until someone musters the will to install these things," he said.

Update 6/12/08: The New Haven Register reports that, following a letter of request from New Haven Mayor John DeStefano, Governor Rell has ordered bicycle storage to be installed on all new M-8 train cars. The article does not say whether bicycles will be allowed on peak-hour trains (even if just in Connecticut) -- a somewhat controversial issue that will most likely have to wait until the beginning of the legislative session.

Update 10/2/08: The Stamford Advocate breaks a story that the state will begin testing out bike racks on trains as early as this month. No word yet on whether bicycles will be allowed on peak-hour trains, despite the potential "smart growth" benefits and reduction in car use in urban centers along the line:

As part of a study about adding more space for bikes in new passenger rail cars, the Department of Transportation later this month will try out bike racks aboard trains on Metro-North's New Haven Line. State officials are considering several wall-mounted rack systems for a pilot program. Gov. M. Jodi Rell asked the agency in the spring to consider ways to allow more bicycles on new train cars, DOT spokesman Kevin Nursick said. The racks likely will be placed in the wheelchair-accessible seating area of train cars, he said. The study hopes to find a way to increase the number of bikes on trains without cutting seats, Nursick said. "We will give these a test run on the current trains and see how they are accepted by the public, and if we get positive or negative feedback, we'll take it into account," he said.

Updated 3/05/09: Elm City Cycling, the Connecticut Sierra Club and many other individuals have submitted public testimony in favor of a bill proposed by Rep. Tom Kehoe that would require access on train cars. For a PDF file of ECC's testimony, click here.